Showing posts with label Alexis de Tocquevill. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Alexis de Tocquevill. Show all posts

Sunday, 24 July 2011

... democracy Peter Black, a reminder ...

... from the great political thinker de Tocqueville.

"Democracy extends the sphere of individual freedom," he said. "Democracy attaches all possible value to each man," ............ "while socialism makes each man a mere agent, a mere number. Democracy and socialism have nothing in common but one word: equality. But notice the difference: while democracy seeks equality in liberty, socialism seeks equality in restraint and servitude".  Said in 1848.

... and today in his blog Peter Black, I thought him the voice of the liberal tradition in Wales, became a tyrant when he wrote ...
"... that raises questions over Murdoch and his company being fit and proper people to own any media in this country. The Americans may be content with Fox News setting the agenda and targeting individual politicians but such practises are anti-democratic and need to be stamped out." ............... restraint and servitude of the left leaning politicians.
... it was the "fit and proper ... and ... stamped out" that quickened my pulse, a term that might be expected from a dictator but not the Welsh Assembly, or is PB taking notice of arch-dictator Edwina Hart.

I'm afraid any media organisation that might bring to book politicians and their associated party is a welcome addition to our fragile pseudo-democracy, such action is not anti-democratic, it is part of democracy, holding to account our elected representatives, if there is a problem  ...

... it is a question of monopoly in the UK media, as has been ably demonstrated by the Murdoch tribe, but monopoly is the enemy of both economics and democracy, and as such can be discouraged through strong monopoly legislation that also encourages competition, good legislation could cover all economic activity

Fortunately for the electorate PB is not involved in this particular legislative arena, else he might "stamp out" other freedoms we value so much.

If the monopoly question is addressed without fear or favour what happens to the BBC .....

Returning to "fit and proper", PB might like to consider the question of "requests for information", by and large ignored by certain ministers, would a WAG minister refuse a request from the Sunday Times I wonder.

Thursday, 7 April 2011

According to Welsh Ramblings, ....

.... you can read it in full here, the difference between Plaid Cymru and the other political parties in Wales is ...

... The Tories don't really have any politics, similarly to the Lib Dems and Labour. They pursue a managerial agenda based on treating voters like consumers and "marketing" short-termist ideas to them ...

Apparently our separatist political party doesn't offer the political carrot to an unwary electorate, I think WR is indulging in a spot of wishful thinking, his particular testimony can be disabused with ease, from the BBC a list of the promises made by Plaid Cymru, its carrots ...

  •  A doctor and dentist when you need one.
  • Support university students by meeting the extra cost of top-up fees for Welsh domiciled students.
  • Continue to fight for a strong Common Agricultural Policy and to maintain the direct payments to Welsh farmers.
  • Create a new Welsh language innovation fund to strengthen Welsh ......
  • Invest across Wales in the retrofitting and insulation of homes ....
  • Create a multi-million pound growth fund .....
  • Continue to provide relative protection for schools, hospitals ...
  • Expand the Flying Start programme to increase the provision of free childcare.

.... and last but not least, transport, the "Big Issue" for WR ...
 Improve rail services and ensure greater investment in the Welsh railways ...
 ... so when in the political glass house it is generally considered good advice not to throw stones, Plaid is no different to any other political party, party of carrots ...

... who was it that said ...
"when politicians discover how to bribe the electorate with their own money democracy will be lost"
When Plaid lost John Dixon, who now describes himself as  ...
... a former Plaid Cymru member, activist, candidate, and national officer, including periods as Party Chair in 1992-3 and 2002-2010. An unrepentant radical who believes strongly that we can reshape economics to serve humanity rather than adapt humanity to serve economics.
... they also became just another resting place for people who would tell us how to live our lives, so Welsh Ramblings, ardent as you might be about your chosen political friends, they are no different to any other group at the Wales Assembly ......... just politicians with their hands in our pockets ........


Update ... it was Alexis de Tocqueville (Democracy in America), an eminent representative of the classical liberal political tradition


 who wrote ...

"The American Republic will endure until the day Congress discovers that it can bribe the public with the public's money."
... politicians learn quick.